The information in this article is up to date for tax year 2024 (returns filed in 2025).
Whether you’re an investment expert or you’re new to the practice of investing, it’s important to consider the tax implications of your investments. ETF tax efficiency can be very high, which makes them a fantastic product to include in your portfolio.
Are you interested in using ETFs to save money on tax? Read on to find out more about ETF tax efficiency.
What Are ETFs?
An ETF (exchanged-traded fund) pools money from many investors and invests it in securities, including bonds, options, equities, and more. These funds are usually passively managed, which means that they track an index. Changes in the index determine which assets inside the fund are bought and sold, rather than relying on the decisions of an individual fund manager.
In contrast, actively managed mutual funds involve fund managers making strategic decisions to outperform benchmark indices, potentially offering higher returns but with different tax implications.
Definition of Tax Efficiency
Tax efficiency refers to the ability of an investment to minimize tax liabilities, thereby maximizing after-tax returns. Tax-efficient investments aim to reduce the impact of taxes on investment returns, allowing investors to retain more of their earnings. By choosing tax-efficient options like ETFs, investors can potentially enhance their overall financial outcomes.
How ETFs Are Created
ETFs are created through a unique process that involves authorized participants (APs) and the ETF manager. APs are large financial institutions that have an agreement with the ETF manager to create or redeem shares in large blocks called creation units. A creation unit typically consists of 10,000 to 150,000 shares. During creation, APs deliver a basket of securities to the issuer in exchange for a creation unit. In a redemption, the process is reversed, and the AP receives a basket of securities while the ETF manager takes back a creation unit. This in-kind process avoids cash transactions that may trigger capital gains distributions. By minimizing these taxable events, ETFs can maintain their tax-efficient status, making them an attractive option for investors looking to reduce their tax liabilities.
Key Features of ETFs
ETFs have several key features that contribute to their tax efficiency.
Exchange Trading
ETFs trade on an exchange, allowing shareholders to redeem shares by selling in the open market. No positions in the underlying portfolio need to be sold for this transaction to occur, reducing capital gains. This exchange-traded structure enables ETFs to distribute fewer capital gains to shareholders than mutual funds. By avoiding frequent buying and selling of securities, investors can minimize their tax liabilities and keep more of their investment returns.
In-Kind Redemption
In-kind redemption allows issuers to take ETF shares off the market when there is too much supply. Market makers can redeem shares in-kind, delivering the underlying positions to the ETF issuer. This process allows ETFs to avoid cash transactions and potential capital gains. In-kind redemptions can result in the fund’s portfolio having unrealized losses instead of gains, further reducing tax liabilities. By leveraging in-kind redemptions, ETFs can maintain their tax efficiency and provide investors with a more tax-advantaged investment option.
How Do ETF Taxes Work?
You must pay taxes on the income you gain from ETFs, whether that income comes from interest, dividends, or capital gains from buying and selling.
The good news is that they can be more tax efficient than other types of investment, such as mutual funds.
ETF vs. Mutual Fund Taxes
Mutual funds are taxed according to the same rules as ETFs. So why are ETFs more tax efficient than mutual funds?
The answer is that mutual funds are actively managed. Mutual fund managers buy and sell securities frequently, which leads to larger tax bills for capital gains.
If you want to reduce your investment tax bill as much as possible, then it might be worth prioritizing ETFs over mutual funds in your portfolio.
Capital Gains vs. Ordinary Income
Let’s take a moment to drill a little deeper into the term “capital gains.” When a security held within a fund (or any other asset) grows in value and then is sold, you have received a “capital gain.”
It’s a legal requirement to pay tax on capital gains, just like you have to pay tax on ordinary income.
Different transactions, such as selling securities, can trigger a taxable event, leading to tax implications for investors. The more buying and selling a fund manager does, the more taxable events occur. Therefore, you can pay a lot more in capital gains tax if you invest mostly in actively managed funds.
ETF vs. Mutual Fund: Tax and Other Considerations
In addition to their tax efficiency, ETFs have other important advantages over mutual funds. Let’s take a look at the key reasons to consider ETFs over mutual funds, besides simply paying less tax, although that in itself is a great reason.
Mutual fund investors may face higher tax bills due to capital gains generated by mutual funds, whereas ETF investors often benefit from more favorable tax treatment and timing of gains recognized.
ETFs are more transparent than mutual funds. You can view changes in your ETF holdings daily, whereas mutual funds only report their holdings once a quarter. If you are the type of investor who likes to know exactly where their money is invested, this could be a better option for you.
ETFs also offer greater liquidity than mutual funds. You can buy and sell holdings at any point during the day. In contrast, mutual fund shares can only be sold or bought at the end of the trading day. Most days, this won’t matter too much, but on those rare days where market prices rise or fall significantly during a single day, it’s a big deal!
You’ll usually also get lower expense ratios with ETFs than with mutual funds. Why not keep more of your money by minimizing expenses as well as taxes?
Is ETF Trading Right For You?
ETFs can provide many benefits if you include them as a part of your overall investment strategy. These funds are designed to help individual investors pay less tax than they would on other types of funds.
For ETF investors, there are specific tax implications to consider, such as the potential for capital gains when selling shares on the secondary market. While ETFs may defer taxes due to in-kind transactions, this does not eliminate tax liabilities for investors.
In addition to ETF tax efficiency, you can benefit from the diverse holdings included in ETFs. This diversity allows you to invest across industries, asset types, and even countries. Just like in life, diversity is a good thing. It allows you to create a balanced portfolio, which can help to limit your exposure to risk.
Remember, all investments are riskier than holding your money in a bank account. However, they also offer the opportunity to earn a much greater return than even a high-yield savings account can offer. Most people benefit from investing as a way of putting aside money for their long-term future.
Key Takeaways
That was an acronym-packed article, so let’s break down the key takeaways one more time:
- ETFs allow you to quickly and easily invest in multiple, diverse assets
- ETFs are more tax efficient than mutual funds
- ETFs also offer higher transparency and liquidity than mutual funds
- Understanding tax efficiencies is crucial when choosing between ETFs and mutual funds, as it impacts taxable investments
So are ETFs a good deal? Yes, they are — at least if you are looking for a tax-efficient way to invest.
ezTaxReturn has everything investors need to file their taxes online. File fast and ez today.
The articles and content published on this blog are provided for informational purposes only. The information presented is not intended to be, and should not be taken as, legal, financial, or professional advice. Readers are advised to seek appropriate professional guidance and conduct their own due diligence before making any decisions based on the information provided.
